Skip to content

Compare

InsuraMate and Upfirst.

Upfirst is an AI answering service for small businesses, priced by calls per month, with a page aimed at insurance agents and brokers. InsuraMate answers your agency’s calls too, then does the work behind them: standard certificates from your AMS, the service inbox, and call notes on the client file.

Side by side

Compare the work covered.

Feature Upfirst InsuraMate AI
What it is AI answering service and virtual receptionist for small businesses, with an insurance page An AI insurance back office: calls, standard certificates, the service inbox and AMS updates
Insurance-specific Quote intake by line, claim intake, policy FAQs from your knowledge base, transfer rules Built only for independent P&C insurance agencies
Who answers AI, 24/7, with warm transfers AI, on your existing number, with handoff to your team by your rules
AMS integrations AgencyZoom, InsuredMine, NowCerts and others through Zapier Nexsure, QQ Catalyst, AMS360, HawkSoft, NowCerts, Applied Epic and EZLynx
Certificates of insurance Not mentioned Standard certificates issued from the policy data in your AMS on written requests, checked and logged. Special wording goes to your licensed team
Service inbox and endorsements Email summaries and two-way texting; no inbox or endorsement work mentioned Service inbox sorted; routine replies drafted for a person to send. Endorsement and policy change requests taken down for a licensed person
Claims calls Walks callers through incident details or texts a link to your claims form; urgent claims can trigger alerts Loss calls routed the way your agency chooses: to the right agent, or straight to the carrier’s claims department
Licensing guardrails Not stated No advice, no quotes and no policy changes. Anything that needs a licensed person is routed by your rules
Setup Most agencies configured in under 30 minutes, as advertised Setup included. Nothing goes live until you approve it
Languages 35+ on the pricing page; over 30 on the insurance page 85 languages, Spanish included
Price $24.95 to $299 a month by calls, plus per-call overage Quoted for your agency. Never metered by the call or the minute

Last verified 9 November 2026, from Upfirst’s own public site. We re-check every quarter. Sources: upfirst.ai/pricingupfirst.ai/industries/insurance

What it costs

Upfirst pricing, side by side with ours.

Every figure below is Upfirst's own published rate, taken from their pricing page on 9 November 2026. These plans are answered by AI. Rates change, so confirm with them before you sign anything.

Plan Price Included
Starter $24.95/mo 30 calls a month ($20/mo billed annually)
Premium $59.95/mo 90 calls a month ($48/mo billed annually)
Pro $159.95/mo 300 calls a month ($128/mo billed annually)
Scale $299/mo 600 calls a month ($240/mo billed annually), white-glove onboarding
Enterprise Custom 1,000+ calls a month

Going over: $1.50 per extra call on Starter, $1 on Premium, 75¢ on Pro and 70¢ on Scale.

Upfirst bills by calls per month. Spam, calls under 15 seconds and calls where the caller never speaks are not billed. Extra agents are $9.95 a month each. There is a 14-day trial (or 100 calls), and no contract.

How we price

Every agency is quoted for its own situation, never per call, per minute or per add-on. Call volume can double in renewal season and our bill does not move.

Setup and connecting your AMS are included in our fee. The number comes in writing the same day as your call with us.

See how our pricing works →
Real scenario

Monday morning after a storm.

A hailstorm went through on Sunday. By Monday morning the phone has rung forty times, and the inbox has twenty emails asking about claims, coverage and certificates for contractors doing repairs.

A per-call plan bills every one of those calls, and the emails are still waiting for a person. With InsuraMate the calls are answered, loss calls are routed the way your agency chose, and the inbox is sorted, with routine replies drafted and standard certificates issued from your AMS. Our fee for that month is the same as for a quiet one.

Where Upfirst wins

Upfirst is cheap to start, publishes every price, and has thought about insurance calls: it collects quote details by line of business, walks callers through a loss report and routes claims, new business and service calls differently. It sets up quickly without a sales call, and texting is included on every plan.

Where InsuraMate AI wins

Upfirst stops at the call. Its AMS connections run through Zapier, and it does not describe certificates, the service inbox or writing to the client file. InsuraMate matches callers to their client record in your AMS, answers routine questions from what is on file, issues standard certificates from the policy data and sorts the inbox. And our fee does not rise with call volume in renewal season.

Who each one is better for.

Upfirst is better for a small agency that wants an AI to answer calls, take quote and claim details and pass them on, at a low monthly price and without a sales conversation. If your volume is small and steady, per-call pricing can be economical.

InsuraMate is better for an agency that wants the work behind the calls done as well: certificates, the service inbox, call notes on the client file and routine questions answered from what is in the AMS. It is built only for insurance agencies.

Switching from Upfirst to InsuraMate.

You keep your number, and there is no gap in coverage.

  • Tell us which AMS and phone system you use, and which hours you want covered.
  • We connect your systems and agree your routing rules, including where loss calls go.
  • Calls move to InsuraMate on your existing number when you approve go-live.
  • Certificates and the service inbox switch on when you approve them.

Questions to ask before you choose.

Upfirst has an insurance page, so the useful questions are about what happens after the call:

  • Does the caller get matched to their client record in your AMS, or does someone look them up later?
  • Is the AMS connection direct, or does it run through Zapier?
  • Who issues the certificate the caller asked for, and when?
  • Who works the emails that arrive after a busy week of calls?
  • What does the bill do in a storm month?

What stays with your licensed team.

InsuraMate handles the routine work and hands over everything that needs judgment: coverage advice, quotes, policy changes, special certificate wording and any caller who asks for a person. Each handover comes with a summary of who called, what they needed and what was already done, so the person picking it up starts at the decision, not at the beginning. Your agency stays the issuer of record on every certificate, and every write-back to your AMS is recorded so your team can see what was done, when and why.

What the back office adds.

Every call ends with a summary. The summary goes wherever your team already works: Microsoft Teams, Slack or another messenger, email, your CRM or your AMS. You choose.

When a caller reports a loss, InsuraMate routes the call the way your agency chooses: to the right agent with the details already taken down, or straight to the carrier’s claims department, so claims never have to go through your office. InsuraMate does not decide anything about the claim; your team and the carrier do.

Over 800 certificates of insurance have been issued with InsuraMate to date.

Choosing your scope

If you want an inexpensive AI that answers calls, takes quote details and claim reports, and connects to your systems through Zapier, Upfirst is worth a look. If you want the calls and the service work behind them done inside your AMS, that is an insurance back office, and it is what InsuraMate does.

Common questions

InsuraMate AI vs Upfirst, answered.

Is there an Upfirst alternative for insurance agencies?

Yes. InsuraMate answers your calls on your existing number and also does the work behind them: standard certificates from your AMS, the service inbox and call notes on the client file. Upfirst answers calls and passes the details on.

How much does Upfirst cost?

On its pricing page, read on 9 November 2026, Upfirst lists Starter at $24.95 a month for 30 calls, Premium at $59.95 for 90, Pro at $159.95 for 300 and Scale at $299 for 600, with per-call overage and 20% off annual billing.

Does Upfirst connect to our AMS?

Upfirst says AgencyZoom, InsuredMine, NowCerts and other platforms connect through Zapier. InsuraMate works directly with Nexsure, QQ Catalyst, AMS360, HawkSoft, NowCerts, Applied Epic and EZLynx.

Can Upfirst issue certificates of insurance?

Upfirst’s site does not mention certificates. InsuraMate issues supported standard certificates from the policy data in your AMS on written requests.

Does InsuraMate charge per call?

No. Every agency is quoted for its own situation, and our fee is never metered by the call or the minute.

Calls are one part of an agency’s back office. See everything an AI insurance back office handles, and how it compares with outsourcing.

See InsuraMate in action.