Compare
InsuraMate and Goodcall.
Goodcall is an AI answering service built for small businesses of every kind, priced by the number of unique callers each month. InsuraMate answers your agency’s calls too, then does the insurance work behind them: standard certificates from your AMS, the service inbox, and call notes on the client file.
Compare the work covered.
| Feature | Goodcall | InsuraMate AI |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | AI answering service and receptionist for small businesses of any kind | An AI insurance back office: calls, standard certificates, the service inbox and AMS updates |
| Insurance-specific | No insurance features stated | Built only for independent P&C insurance agencies |
| Who answers | AI, 24/7. Callers are told they are speaking with an AI assistant | AI, on your existing number, with handoff to your team by your rules |
| AMS integrations | None named. HighLevel, Google Calendar, Zapier and an API | Nexsure, QQ Catalyst, AMS360, HawkSoft, NowCerts, Applied Epic and EZLynx |
| Certificates of insurance | Not offered | Standard certificates issued from the policy data in your AMS on written requests, checked and logged. Special wording goes to your licensed team |
| Service inbox and endorsements | Not offered. Leads are sent to the business by text or email | Service inbox sorted; routine replies drafted for a person to send. Endorsement and policy change requests taken down for a licensed person |
| Claims calls | No claims handling stated | Loss calls routed the way your agency chooses: to the right agent, or straight to the carrier’s claims department |
| Licensing guardrails | Not stated; you build the call flows | No advice, no quotes and no policy changes. Anything that needs a licensed person is routed by your rules |
| Setup | Self-serve: build, test and approve your agent | Setup included. Nothing goes live until you approve it |
| Languages | Not stated | 85 languages, Spanish included |
| Price | $79 to $299 a month, billed by unique customer, plus Enterprise | Quoted for your agency. Never metered by the call or the minute |
Last verified 9 November 2026, from Goodcall’s own public site. We re-check every quarter. Sources: goodcall.com/pricinggoodcall.com
Goodcall pricing, side by side with ours.
Every figure below is Goodcall's own published rate, taken from their pricing page on 9 November 2026. These plans are answered by AI. Rates change, so confirm with them before you sign anything.
| Plan | Price | Included |
|---|---|---|
| Starter | $79/mo | 100 unique customers a month (about 150 calls), 1 external tool, 1 team member, 30-day call history |
| Growth | $129/mo | 500 unique customers (about 750 calls), 5 external tools, 5 team members, 90-day history |
| Scale | $299/mo | 2,000 unique customers (about 3,000 calls), 15 external tools, 10 team members, unlimited history |
| Enterprise | Custom | More than 2,000 customers a month or several connected systems |
Going over: extra unique customers are billed at the plan rate: 79¢ each on Starter, 26¢ on Growth and 15¢ on Scale.
Goodcall bills by unique customer (one phone number, once a month) and says it never meters minutes. A local number is included on every plan.
Every agency is quoted for its own situation, never per call, per minute or per add-on. Call volume can double in renewal season and our bill does not move.
Setup and connecting your AMS are included in our fee. The number comes in writing the same day as your call with us.
See how our pricing works →Wednesday, 5:50 PM. A contractor needs a certificate tonight.
A contractor calls just after you close: the general contractor wants a certificate before the crew starts at 7. Goodcall would answer, take a message and send it to you by text or email. Somebody at your agency still has to issue the certificate.
With InsuraMate the call is answered on your existing number, and the contractor is asked to send the request in writing. When the email arrives it is matched to the client and the policy, checked against the policy data in your AMS, and the standard certificate is issued, sent and logged. If the general contractor wants additional insured wording, it waits for your licensed team with the reason it stopped.
Goodcall is inexpensive, quick to try and publishes its prices. You can build a demo agent before you pay, and a busy month costs a few cents per extra caller rather than a jump to a new plan. For a small business that only needs the phone answered and leads captured, that is hard to argue with.
An insurance call rarely ends when the caller hangs up. Someone still has to find the client in the AMS, issue the certificate, answer the email that follows and write the note. InsuraMate does that work: callers are matched to their client record, standard certificates are issued from the policy data, the service inbox is sorted and the call note lands on the client file. That is the difference between an answering service and an AI insurance back office.
Who each one is better for.
Goodcall is better for a small business outside insurance, or an agency that only wants the phone answered and is happy to build its own call flows and do the follow-up work by hand. Its pricing is public and low, and you can start without talking to anyone.
InsuraMate is better for an independent agency where calls lead to service work: certificates, billing and policy questions, loss reports, endorsement requests and notes in the AMS. It is built only for insurance, and the work finishes in your systems.
Switching from Goodcall to InsuraMate.
Moving over does not mean a new number or a gap in coverage.
- Tell us which AMS and phone system you use, and which hours you want covered.
- We connect your systems and agree your routing rules, including where loss calls go.
- Calls move to InsuraMate on your existing number when you approve go-live.
- Certificates and the service inbox switch on when you approve them; most agencies start certificates with review copies.
Questions to ask before you choose.
Whichever way you go, these are the questions that separate an answering service from an insurance back office:
- Does it know who the caller is, from your AMS, before the conversation starts?
- Can it answer a billing or policy question from what is on file, or only take a message?
- What happens to a certificate request, and who issues it?
- Where does the call note end up: in an email, or on the client file?
- What does the bill do in renewal season, when call volume doubles?
What stays with your licensed team.
InsuraMate handles the routine work and hands over everything that needs judgment: coverage advice, quotes, policy changes, special certificate wording and any caller who asks for a person. Each handover comes with a summary of who called, what they needed and what was already done, so the person picking it up starts at the decision, not at the beginning. Your agency stays the issuer of record on every certificate, and every write-back to your AMS is recorded so your team can see what was done, when and why.
What the back office adds.
Every call ends with a summary. The summary goes wherever your team already works: Microsoft Teams, Slack or another messenger, email, your CRM or your AMS. You choose.
When a caller reports a loss, InsuraMate routes the call the way your agency chooses: to the right agent with the details already taken down, or straight to the carrier’s claims department, so claims never have to go through your office. InsuraMate does not decide anything about the claim; your team and the carrier do.
Over 800 certificates of insurance have been issued with InsuraMate to date.
If you need a low-cost AI to answer the phone and capture leads, and you are happy to build the call flows yourself, Goodcall is a reasonable choice. If the calls are the start of insurance work (certificates, policy questions, loss reports, notes in the AMS), you need a back office, not only an answering service.
InsuraMate AI vs Goodcall, answered.
Is there a Goodcall alternative built for insurance agencies?
Yes. InsuraMate answers your agency’s calls on your existing number and then does the insurance work behind them: standard certificates from your AMS, the service inbox and call notes on the client file. Goodcall is a general answering service for small businesses.
How much does Goodcall cost?
On its pricing page, read on 9 November 2026, Goodcall lists Starter at $79 a month, Growth at $129 and Scale at $299, billed by unique customers per month, with Enterprise priced on request.
Does Goodcall integrate with insurance agency management systems?
Goodcall’s site names HighLevel, Google Calendar, Zapier and an API, and no agency management system. InsuraMate works with Nexsure, QQ Catalyst, AMS360, HawkSoft, NowCerts, Applied Epic and EZLynx.
Can Goodcall issue certificates of insurance?
Goodcall does not describe certificate issuing. InsuraMate issues supported standard certificates from the policy data in your AMS on written requests, and sends special wording to your licensed team.
How is InsuraMate priced?
Every agency is quoted for its own situation. Our fee is never metered by the call or the minute, and setup is included.
Do we have to change our phone number?
No. InsuraMate answers on your existing number, at the hours you choose.
Calls are one part of an agency’s back office. See everything an AI insurance back office handles, and how it compares with outsourcing.